- Show off your style cents in the comfortably constructed Johnston & Murphy® Maggie Penny loafer.
- Patent leather upper.
- Easy slip-on style.
- Soft leather lining for an excellent feel and wear.
- Footbed is generously cushioned with memory foam for all-day comfort.
- Flexible rubber outsole features unique design for added traction.
- Imported.
- Product measurements were taken using size 8, width N. Please note that measurements may vary by size.
- Measurements:
- Weight: 8 oz
Johnston & Murphy Maggie Penny | Loafers
$99.00 Original price was: $99.00.$64.35Current price is: $64.35.
- Multiple payment methods, safe and reliable
- 7-Day Returns, 100% Quality
- Protecting Your Payment Information
- 100% Quality Promise

| Color | Black Washed Sheepskin, Tan Washed Sheepskin |
|---|---|
| size | 10, 6, 6.5, 7, 7.5, 8.5, 9, 9.5 |
| width | M |
25 reviews for Johnston & Murphy Maggie Penny | Loafers
Add a review Cancel reply
Related products
-30%
Rated 4.44 out of 5
-30%
Rated 4.92 out of 5
-30%
Rated 4.88 out of 5
-34%
Rated 5.00 out of 5
-29%
-33%
Rated 4.55 out of 5
-22%
Rated 4.54 out of 5
-43%
























Chris T –
this shoe is classy looking and fits true to size. there is no gapping at the sides and the heel fits well-no slipping. they are also very comfortable so far-haven’t worn them for any amount of time. they look great!
Lori –
I already own three pairs of the non-patent leather Maggie Penny shoes and love them. I wanted to love these too but the fit of the patent leather version of this shoe is just not the same. The shoe felt tight and restrictive – not at all comfortable. The plain leather version is soft and almost like wearing a comfortable slipper. Not the same with this version. Sadly, I’m sending these ones back.
Julie S –
Very good looking shoe. Well made and well cushioned. The patent leather is a bit stiff at first but I can already feel it breaking in.
Annette –
Very good looking. Love the white nubs on back of heel. Comfortable from first step and work w lots of my clothes. Might even look for two shiny half dollars to slid under the top band! Never give 5 * so 4 is a great # for me.
Anonymous –
Thought I’ll be comfortable. But just wearing it five minutes my feet burns
Britta –
I bought my regular size, which felt snug straight out of the box (expected) and broke in quickly to form to my foot, as expected for high quality soft leather. I wore them around the house today before wearing them to work, so I’m hoping for more great performance. I did fear heel or pinkie toe blisters, and did feel what felt like the start of a worrisome spot on my pinkie toes, but that quickly passed as the soft leather formed to my foot. The navy is dark enough to be a dark shoe, but still clearly a blue which is a nice change from brown/black. I wish these came in some bright colors.
Anonymous –
The shoe itself is a very nice loafer, unfortunately it was probably two sizes to small.
Anonymous –
Beautiful shoe but so narrow that I couldn’t get my foot even past the toes. Returned.
Anonymous –
Love these! They’re very comfortable.
Anonymous –
Very narrow feeling and I don’t have a wide foot.
Anonymous –
l liked these shoes but unfortunately they were too wide and gapped on both sides of my foot. Had to return.:(
Anonymous –
I needed a shoe with strong arch support. This is not the shoe though cute, nice leather and what I was looking for
Lori –
comfortable and easy to walk in. Looks nice on the foot. Order a 1/2 to full size up, runs small
Lia –
Great looking loafers in real life. They do run small, I usually wear an 8 in women’s but had to increase to 9. Overall, pretty good experience. JM made the exchange process very easy, and they were very responsive when I emailed for a status update.
Amanda –
Shoes were exactly what I expected for a loafer, however they were extremely narrow. I never have an issue with shoes not being wide enough. Had to return these as there was no way I could ever comfortably wear them.
Cassandra –
Beautiful loafer!
Jean –
Just a bit narrow in the toes
Carol –
great fit – love the look
Stacy –
Very comfortable, very stylish. Love these shoes.
Sarah –
Excellent color, fit, material, price and service!
Sharon –
I love all of my shoes from Johnston and Murphy and will continue to buy them.
LAllen –
Shoe runs small narrow. Toe box not tall enough, pressure on big toe . I’m thinking I will need a half size up.
Anonymous –
This shoe was a bit too small so I ended up returning it. I wasn’t impressed by the quality of the leather (my pair looked a little wrinkled on top) so I wasn’t interested in an exchange.
Yvonne –
Like them fine. The leather was soft which is what I wanted.!
Anonymous –
Finally, a pair of shoes I really like. These shoes look like they are made well; the left and right shoes are the same size and they look the same. They were just a bit tight in the width, but they will be fine after I wear them. I really, really like these shoes.